[MANNYHOF24]

Originally Posted by Coco's Disciples

In prior instances we have seen manifestations of the smoke monster, i.e. Walt and Yemi. I don't really know what to make of Christian and Claire and Miles. I think its one of: a) Miles saw Christian, because Christian is really there. b) Miles saw Christian because he can see dead people. c) Miles didn't see Christian, just saw Claire say "dad" and leave.

Another note that I have to give my dad credit for: Jack didn't have a scar on his appendix area in the flashforward. Perhaps Hurley was right?

He actually did, however its not as noticable as you would think. The flashforward did take place almost three years after the surgery though.