Jump to content
Talk Sox
  • Create Account

Recommended Posts

Posted
we need a stop gap, that much is for certain. And it isnt like Cameron doesnt work walks. He's walked 193 times over the last 3 yrs. Its the BA that drives the OBP down. But what I'd want to see is if he can still go get it. If he doesnt have that great fielder's instinct and first step, then I dont want him. We need a CFer with a good arm AND solid range. Gardner has the range, not so much on the arm. Melky has the arm, but not the range. Jackson has both but isnt ready yet. Cameron would be a solid addition on the defensive side while providing power at the bottom of the order. The only other options are either in house or Mark Kotsay, who is in obvious decline. Aned the in house options include Melky, who had the worst season of any yankee OFer ever, Gardner, who is a notoriously slow starter and should get his work in at AAA before a mid yr callup, and Jackson, who did well in AA but obviously needs one more yr of seasoning
Posted
You don't need a stopgap. Gardner would be an adequate fill player until Jackson is ready. He might even surprise you. And you could do worse than giving Melky one last shot for that matter.
Posted
You don't need a stopgap. Gardner would be an adequate fill player until Jackson is ready. He might even surprise you. And you could do worse than giving Melky one last shot for that matter.

God help us if Melky is in CF.

 

Neither Gardner or Melky are anything more than a 4th OF at best. I am hoping we aquire Manny and move Damon to CF.

 

You know what would be funny? Imagine for a second we signed Manny and put him at DH. You'd have Matsui in LF and Damon in CF. You could see Gardner and Melky play every game the Yankees have a lead in the 7th and beyond.

 

That being said, I don't want Cameron. There are much better options than he.

Posted

What are they? Damon is a TERRIBLE CFer. AND, Matsui cannot play LF on a chronic basis. We arent getting Beltran. McLouth is not coming to NY. Here are the FA options.

 

Kotsay- wouldnt mind it, but Cameron is better

Cameron- probably the best option all around

Griffey- he isnt an OFer anymore

Edmonds- he wont come to NY and he is a s***** CFer right now

Patterson- he is Cameron without the power, patience, or defense

DaVanon, Matos, Clark, etc. They suck.

Posted
God help us if Melky is in CF.

 

Neither Gardner or Melky are anything more than a 4th OF at best. I am hoping we aquire Manny and move Damon to CF.

 

You know what would be funny? Imagine for a second we signed Manny and put him at DH. You'd have Matsui in LF and Damon in CF. You could see Gardner and Melky play every game the Yankees have a lead in the 7th and beyond.

 

That being said, I don't want Cameron. There are much better options than he.

That would be one terrible defensive outfield. I'm not against the ideaof getting Manny, but no way Damon should be our regular centerfielder, and no way in hell should Hideki be in left everyday. I still think we should let Matsui or Damon play first, but the organization seems reluctant to do so.

  • 2 weeks later...
Posted
Sounds like a trade will be in order.

Can you trade a player who you just picked up an option/arbitration?

Posted
Can you trade a player who you just picked up an option/arbitration?

Yeah. Even a Free Agent who you resigned I believe. I think you only have to wait until June 15 when you sign a player from another team.

Posted
I know if you trade a player in the first year of a multi-year contract, that player has the right to opt out of his deal. I am not sure with options and arbitration. Thanks for the clarification.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
The Talk Sox Caretaker Fund
The Talk Sox Caretaker Fund

You all care about this site. The next step is caring for it. We’re asking you to caretake this site so it can remain the premier Red Sox community on the internet.

×
×
  • Create New...