Nomar or Pokey

[nomar]

In no way is this my opinion, but I heard someone say this and I thought it would be an interesting debate. Is Nomar's bat more important, or Pokey's defense. I think Nomar by far, but it has been argued the other way around.

[yeszir]

Nomar's bat, without question.

[ACL BoSox]

And for the record, Nomar is not too shabby defensively as well.

[RoyNHSox]

No-brainer that Nomar’s bat is superior, but defensively I'd have to give the edge to Reese. His quickness and range I'd say seems better than Nomar’s, who is by far no slouch himself.

But if the discussion was would Pokey be capable in taking over the SS position next year if Nomar walks..? Well I'd have to say yes, but obviously the bat would have to be made up elsewhere in the lineup.

[Benny9Sox7]

i think nomar is more important than pokey all around..... Nomars bat is way better than reese and the only reason nomar makes more errors than others is because he gets to more balls than alot of players with his great range and then he ends up throwing some away but the thin is he still gets to more balls