Crisp was WAY more productive. Wait....Originally Posted by Yaz Sideburn;573920;
Damon signed with the Yankees from 2006-2009. His numbers crush Crisp's.
Ellsbury didnt become productive on his own until 2008, and Damon had a much better yr in 2008. In 2009, both were very productive, and Ellsbury would take the cake, but by a slim margin in my book. So you're "cheap option" saw a major drop in production for the first 3 yrs of a 4 yr deal with the 4th yr being slightly in your favor