Originally Posted by
jacksonianmarch
These Yankees are loaded for bear now. I thought we'd be getting Santana under the Christmas tree. Little did I know that we'd be jettisoning Castro and getting Stanton. Now looking at this lineup, it is positively insane how much power is here
1. Brett Gardner- LF- Gardy had a resurgent 2017 with a near 4 WAR season. He set a new career high with 21HR and put together a solid 20-20 season going along with 23 steals. His defense rebounded to just above average after a few years where he trailed off. Now long in the tooth at 34 years old and under control through 2018 with an option for 2019, Gardner needs to continue putting up solid numbers in order to stick around beyond 2018. He will likely take the lion's share of time in LF with a fair amount of CF time to get Giancarlo in the field. I wonder if Gardy can crack another 20 HRs, but his swing is made for Yankee Stadium and he hasn't shown any signs of slowing down yet
2. Aaron Judge- RF- The ROY winner and runner up MVP had a season for the ages in 2017. 52 bombs, an OPS over 1.000 and good enough baserunning and defensive metrics to not be a hit only player. Now the daunting question of, can he repeat this will arise. I think he can. I anticipate that this kid has a 60HR season in him, especially playing in Yankee Stadium for half his games. He goes the other way with authority just about as good as the #3 hitter in the lineup, and with the RF porch so short, he should continue to rack up HR after HR
3. Giancarlo Stanton- DH- Stanton will likely take the most assignments at DH of anyone on the roster, but is still looking at over 100 games in the field. Giancarlo hit 59 bombs playing in the 3rd toughest stadium to hit HR in. Now he moves to NY where he can reach the seats in LF with the best of them and also poke one out to RF on a whim. He is also not just a pull hitter as he hits the ball to CF or RF 56% of the time for his career. Stanton is a complete power hitter. He takes tons of walks, strikes out a ton and hits an inordinate amount of HRs. His SLG of .631 last season was the highest in baseball since Harper went over that mark in 2015. He also hit 32 doubles as well. In this lineup, he will immediately become the focal point. I anticipate his HR numbers and his walk numbers to rise. Batting after Judge and his .400+OBP will likely lead to more RBI's for the big righty. Adding Giancarlo to this team makes the rich richer, and adds another gigantic power hitter alongside the even more massive Judge
4. Greg Bird- 1B- Injured for 2016 and the better part of 2017, Greg Bird became an afterthought on a Yankee club moving toward the playoffs in 2017. Once he finally healed from an ankle ailment, he didn't disappoint. He whacked 8HR and had a near .900OPS from Aug 26th through the end of the regular season then OPS'd .938 in 13 postseason contests, crushing 3 more homeruns. If Bird enters the year healthy, he is a legitimate 35HR threat. He has a beautiful left handed swing that will fit very well in the Bronx. He also has a very good eye that should only sharpen with more time in the bigs. He is a big time sleeper for NY, but with the new look bash brothers ahead of him, he should be an absolute force to be reckoned with in 2018.
5. Gary Sanchez- C- Gary Sanchez quietly reached 50HR faster than any catcher in baseball history. Yes, faster than Piazza, Posada, Berra, Bench, Howard, Campanella. All of them. Gary is only the third catcher in major league history to put up 30+HR in his first or second season with Piazza and Rudy York being the only other 2....And Sanchez's "rookie" campaign was all of 53 games. Sanchez swatted 33 HR and drove in 90 in 2017 with a WAR of 4.4 and that is with him missing a month. He was squarely on his way to a 40HR campaign and he is only going to get better. Now batting behind the twin towers and a high OBP guy like Bird, Sanchez should have plenty of opportunities to drive in runs. Now no longer the focal point of the offense, Gary can enjoy being a great player in a loaded lineup. The one caveat for Gary is the defense suffered in 2017. Sanchez got into Girardi's doghouse for his inability to block balls. Sanchez says he lost some flexibility by putting on 20 lbs of muscle after 2016. He intends on losing some and becoming quicker. We shall see if it works. As it stands, I anticipate Gary will catch around 100 games for the Yankees. While the blocking isn't there, his arm is as good as it gets.
6. Didi Gregorius- SS- Didi Gregorius hit the most HR by a Yankee SS ever in 2017 at 25. He also smacked some big ones in the playoffs. Didi is fresh off another career season and saw his WAR jump to 3.9. He doesn't walk, but he also doesn't strike out a lot. In a lineup led off by 5 guys with high K numbers, having a guy like DD around isn't a bad thing. Didi also was as clutch as it got. He hit .253 with a .718OPS with nobody on base, but hit .327 with runners on and .304 with RISP. Didi is entering his walk year and would do well to put up another career season setting himself up for a big extension in NY
7. Aaron Hicks- CF- Hicks paid dividends after the Yankees got him for our former backup catcher. Hicks played elite defense in CF and hit for power and reached base when he played. Twice injuring his obliques, he misses a fair amount of time and was limited to 301AB. But in those 303 ABs, he put up 3.3 WAR. Hicks' history as flamed out former top prospect to reclamation project makes for great drama, but it also doesn't allow for much extrapolation. Prior to getting hurt, his OPS was over .900. After getting hurt, it was .715 and he really struggled in the post season. Hicks has always been death vs lefties, but this past year he was good against righties as well with an .800+OPS. If he proves 2017 was no fluke, then he cements the top 7 in the lineup. If he spirals down to his prior career norms, then he becomes the RH portion of a platoon or fades out entirely. Either way, here is to hoping Hicks 2017 version is here to stay
8. Chase Headley 3B- Headley got moved around the diamond and by playoff time, wasn't playing at all. But with 2018 on the horizon, Headley figures to be a placeholder for up and coming rookie Miguel Andujar. Headley quietly put up 1.9WAR and a .352OBP. If he reaches base at a similar clip, he will be more than just a placeholder. His power has almost completely eroded down to 10-15HR on a season. He will be a FA after 2018, so one must wonder if he has a last gasp before another payday. I wont hold my breath
9. Gleyber Torres 2B- Lets be entirely honest. Tyler Wade or Ronald Torreyes will probably start the season as the 2b and they'll keep Torres down for a few weeks to delay his service clock and just get back into the swing of things in his return from TJS on his non throwing elbow. But unless someone just goes apeshit, Torres is going to take this job. Torres is the #1 prospect in baseball for a reason. He turns 21 in 4 days and has already made it up to AAA. He was the AFL MVP in 2016 and hit .309 with a .406OBP in a brief 23 game cameo in AAA. The guy also plays elite level defense as a SS, so shifting to 2b should actually be easier. Torres has the contact tool to hit for a high average. He has the eye to take a lot of walks. He has gap power now that is expected to blossom into 25+HR power later. This lineup is so deep that it can carry a rookie through some struggles. Should Gleyber prove not to be ready, other options are Tyler Wade who hit .310 in AAA as a 22 yr old and earned a cameo in the bigs last yr and Ronald Torreyes, a steady yet unspectacular super sub capable of being a replacement level player with a good glove and almost no walks or power.