They did, but Correia was a top talent and was someone they liked at 1 as well. If there are equal grades on a player and one costs less, go for it. But to draft a guy with a lower grade due to cost savings to grab someone who is free falling who might not be there at pick 2 is a risky game to play
Hal sucks
Here's Baseball America's mock draft 2012:
https://www.baseballamerica.com/stor...ft-2-0-may-25/
6. Correa
8. D Marrero
The Bleacher Report and others had Correa going 3rd.
When you say it's gonna happen now
When exactly do you mean?
I wouldn't be surprised if Hoglund ends up being the best SP to come out of round 1. You just never know how things will unfold. Classic example: how many pitchers were taken in front of Roger Clemons in round 1 in the 1983 draft?
Take Hoglund at 4, sign him to a below slot deal, and then spend that extra money in round 2. I'm leaning toward a SP in round 1, just because the Red Sox are loaded with position prospect studs already: Downs, Duran, Casas, Jimenez. And a few other position prospects could develop into major talents, such as Yorke and Jordan. With this level of talent in the system, the Red Sox can easily fill in a few holes through free agency.
But the position of catcher is completely different and you often can't rely on free agency to find an elite catcher, which is why H.Davis is also an intriguing choice.
I think you should always take who you think is the best player, regardless of position or slot money considerations, unless you have 2 or more players rated very similarly, which could be the case at pick #4, this year.
That being said, I hope the Sox rate a college pitcher highly enough to take at pick 4. If they take someone else, I'll trust they know more than I do or even all the mock draft sites.
I will add something about catchers: catching prospects are probably the hardest to "get right." Some that are "gotten right" end up being moved to other positions.
Although I often frown on anecdotal evidence, like the case of Roger Clemens, think of all the highly or somewhat highly rated young catchers we've had in our system (some by trade) who flopped (some moved up after being drafted by showing promise in the minors or early majors- I won't add Salty to this list):
Kole Cottam (130th pick in 2018.)
Austin Rei (81st pick in 2015.)
Jon Denny (81st pick in 2013.)
Swihart (26th pick in 2011- man, that was THAT long ago?)
Lavarnway (was a 6th rd pick, though with Federowicz taken the next rd.)
Kottaras (PTBNL in David Wells trade, and he actually went on to put up some decent numbers in MLB after being waived.)
Schoppach (The one we got right: we traded away. 2nd rd 2001.)
Marzano (taken in first round back in 1984)
Marc Sullivan (2nd rd in 1979)
Note: We did take Carlton Fisk in the first round in 1967, and that worked out well, but that was so long ago.
When you say it's gonna happen now
When exactly do you mean?
I trust that Bloom will make the right decision at 4. His moves have been brilliant so far. And so if the Red Sox take the High School Shortstop at 4, over the catcher and Hoglund, that decision will be based on the belief that that Shortstop is supremely talented and too good to pass on.
As much as I would think this team needs to build up it's MiLB pitching, if they take a HS shortstop, I can see why. My first thought was "You don't build up your pitching by drafting high school shortstops," but maybe you do. If, say, Mayer or Lawlor (and/or Yorke) pan out at the lower levels and become ranked prospects, it is possible they can be dealt for a pitcher more established in the MiLB ranks or whom already has MLB experience, which is a lot less risky than taking even a college pitcher...
True, but right now the Sox have a lot of shortstops under 21 in the system. Lugo, Bonaci, Flores. They really only need one on hand for the parent club.
Of course, "high school shortstop" often just means "best player on the team" and it's real common for those guys to find another position before they reach the Majors...
Rocker to the Sox- hints at big drop off after pick 4...
https://www.mlb.com/news/pipeline-po...draft-coverage
When you say it's gonna happen now
When exactly do you mean?