I do think the Yankee roster is good and deep, and I still like your farm more than ours, but I put the question out there.
It seems like there is a solid argument for both of the opposite positions.
Are the Yanks really as good as the press and ranking services claim? If yes, why have they not come close to winning a ring or look like they will anytime soon?
Are the Yankees really this bad? Their recent season's records say no, and they are under performing, this year or managed poorly.
I wasn't really taking a side, except I'm a firm believer that Boone is a baboon. They should be winning more than they are, so yes, I agree it looks like Cashman has done better than Boone, but IMO, they both need to go. Too many very bad decisions by both.