It’s true.
Wagner was naturally right-handed, but he broke his right arm twice playing football. He was also, as you noticed, rather short for a pitcher.
But this maybe 5’9” undersized hillbilly made it all the way to MLB by throwing 100mph with his weak arm. That alone makes him worthy of Cooperstown IMO. And then you throw on top of that the dominant statistics that he accomplished.
Wagner is a glaring omission IMO…
That was the era whereby richer teams gamed the system to add comp picks.
The Rays mastered it as low spending team, often trading for players who would have comp picks attached just for the picks. In 2011, they had 9 picks in the first round (top 60 picks) and 2 in the 2nd for 10 in the top 89 picks!- one was Blake Snell, but nobody else did great.
In 2013, they got Stanek for losing BJ Upton. They really did not use all those draft picks very well.
When you say it's gonna happen now
When exactly do you mean?
Here's the list:
2003:
Matt Murton & Abe Alvarez for Cliff Floyd
2005:
Ellsbury Lowrie for OCab (made that trade the deal that just kept giving- see 2014)
Hansen & Bowden for DLowe (Later, Hansen helped us get J Bay)
Buchholz & Egan for Pedro
2006:
Bard & K Johnson for Damon
Clay & Bates for Mueller
2007:
Hagadone for Gonzo (Part of trade that got us VMart)
R Dent for Foulke
2008:
B Price for Gagne
2010:
Vitek & Ranaudo for Wagner (Later, Ranaudo was traded for Robbie Ross.)
Workman & Brentz for J Bay (Later, Workman & Hembree got us Pivetta)
2011:
Barnes & Owens for VMart
JBJ & Swihart for Beltre (Later, Swi was traded for Marcus Wilson)
2012:
B Johnson & P Light for Papelbon (Light was later traded for Abad.)
Ben
2014:
Kopech for Ellsbury (Later, helped us get Sale.)
When you say it's gonna happen now
When exactly do you mean?