19 bold predictions for MLB in 2019

[BillyWilliams]

19 bold predictions for MLB in 2019

01:39
Dec. 31st, 2018

By Anthony Castrovince MLB.com @castrovince

When the New Year arrives, we aim to be more dedicated, more disciplined versions of our natural selves. We vow to bring something good and useful and meaningful to the world.

And yet, for all the "New Year, new you" resolve in the air right now, some of us still just can't help ourselves: We like to make bad baseball predictions.

Here are 19 of them for '19 (and I of course reserve the right to update these to even worse predictions once the offseason dust settles).

1. The Red Sox will barely make the playoffs
Boston is far too talented and the American League has too many suspect squads for me to pick against the Sox reaching the postseason at all. But it will be via the second AL Wild Card spot, and the defending champs will not get back to the World Series.

Why, you ask? Because of Chris Sale's left shoulder? Nathan Eovaldi's October workload? Some kind of statistical setback for Mookie Betts and/or J.D. Martinez?

Nah. I just don't think your fans can break the World Series trophy with an errant beer can without some sort of penalty from the baseball gods.

2. Bryce Harper will sign with the Cardinals
At this point, my head still says that Harper will wind up with the Phillies or the White Sox. But this is the prediction I made at the start of the Hot Stove season, and, darn it, I'm going down with the ship, with all the accumulated evidence sinking me fast.

I do maintain that the Cardinals have the resources to pull it off and need to veer from an established organizational course of short-term solutions and half-measures. Paul Goldschmidt was a great get, but only for one year (and he's 31). Harper would take this club from borderline National League Central contender to clear World Series-caliber squad.

3. The Astros will trade for J.T. Realmuto
And Kyle Tucker? Despite the reports about the Astros balking at the Marlins' current asking price, you're going to look good in Miami blue and caliente red, bud. Speaking of the 'Stros…

4. Carlos Correa will win the AL Most Valuable Player Award over Mike Trout
Steamer is projecting Trout to be worth 9.3 Wins Above Replacement this year. I know to some of you that sentence might as well have come from a medical dictionary, but what that means is that a cold and utterly rational projection system is pegging Trout to have roughly one of the top 100 individual position player seasons of all-time. That's how ridiculous this has gotten. Greatness from Trout is simply expected.

So picking against Trout is also ridiculous. But it's still hard to be sold on the Angels, overall, and voters notoriously (and wrongly) hold team standing against Trout. Every year, there's some other guy who has an insane season (in 2018, it was Betts) that challenges Trout's MVP bid, and this year it will be the full-on Correa explosion, thanks to better health and a stronger (and healthier) supporting lineup cast.

5. Manny Machado will sign in the next 10 days
And he will sign with the Yankees. Not all predictions have to be bold predictions, folks.

6. Madison Bumgarner will become an Atlanta Brave
It won't happen prior to the start of the 2019 season, but Bumgarner will build up just enough trade value to be viewed as a viable upgrade to the Braves' rotation in the midst of the NL East race this summer.

7. Jacob deGrom will win 20 games
Let's just say he's due.

8. The Nationals will win the NL East
What would have been a bland prediction a year ago becomes a bit of a bold one now, with Harper, in all likelihood, leaving and the Nats coming off one of the more disastrous seasons by a clear contender in recent memory. The NL East is setting up to be the baseball equivalent of the "Anchorman" news team fight, but the Nats -- buoyed by a strong rotation, the second season of the Juan Soto experience and an NL Rookie of the Year Award bid from Victor Robles -- will be the rare team that loses a star (perhaps even to a division foe in Philly) and somehow gets better.

Or, you know, they'll re-sign Harper and everybody will pick them. Either way.

9. Ichiro Suzuki will hit a home run in the season-opening Japan Series
And No. 118 will push him past Ty Cobb and tie him with Wade Boggs as he wraps up an incredible, indelible career.

10. Somebody other than Vladimir Guerrero Jr. will win the AL Rookie of the Year Award
This prediction is not a knock on Guerrero himself, as I see no reason why the No. 1 prospect in the game won't have a strong transition to the Major League level in 2019. This is just about swimming against the stream of what I'm sure will be darn near unanimous assumption that Guerrero will win the AL's rookie prize. I'm predicting strong showings from White Sox outfielder Eloy Jimenez and Astros starter Josh James that push Vlad Jr. in the rookie race.

11. There will be a three-man BBWAA Hall of Fame class
Mariano Rivera is a lock, Roy Halladay is not a lock but is not far off and the voters will have done the right thing in getting Edgar Martinez over that final hump. But I see the 2019 vote as coming agonizingly short of the 75-percent threshold for Mike Mussina, who pitched his entire 18-season career in the brutal AL East in the 1990s and 2000s and came out with a better career ERA+ than Bob Feller.

We'll see you in 2020, Moose, alongside your former teammate, Derek Jeter.

12. The Rays will win the AL's top Wild Card spot
Not only will Yandy Diaz turn all that exit velocity into dingers, but Tampa Bay will have something that resembles an actual starting rotation.

13. A team other than the Rays will lead the Majors in "starts by a reliever"
I've got my eye on the A's, for whom MC Hammer is currently penciled in as the No. 3 starter. (Please, Hammer, don't hurt 'em.)

14. The Indians will not trade Trevor Bauer or Corey Kluber
And Bauer will win the AL Cy Young Award, thanks in part to his invention of a new form of breaking ball that strikes batters out and then talks trash about them on Twitter.

15. The Padres will be this year's "Wait, how are they this good?" team
They won't make the postseason, but San Diego will be one of those teams that cause you to look up at the standings in late July and go, "Huh?"

The Padres will beef up their win total a bit against the rebuilding Giants and D-backs, get some nice contributions from Fernando Tatis Jr., Luis Urias and Francisco Mejia, see a little bit of a bounce back from Eric Hosmer and, like the 2018 Rays, try some unusual mixing and matching with their pitching staff.

16. Rhys Hoskins will win the Home Run Derby
This is the best guess I can muster this early, and only because Hoskins was so certain about wanting to do the event again after competing in last year's Derby. Also, the All-Star Game is Cleveland, where the airport is named Hopkins, so there's probably good wordplay to be had if Hoskins hits a bunch of fly balls.

(Although I'm not ruling out Trevor Story winning it and inspiring "Cleveland Rox" headlines.)

17. The Cubs will win the NL pennant
Another one of those that wouldn't have been very bold a year ago, but now? The rotation looks old and iffy, Kris Bryant's coming off a right shoulder injury, the bullpen is a big question (particularly with Brandon Morrow on the shelf) and Joe Maddon is a lame duck.

Fear not, North Siders. While you are going to lose the NL Central to Bryce Harper's Cardinals, you're going to advance in October on the heels of Bryant's return to MVP-caliber form and the Darvish Redemption Tour. Darvish's story will have shades of the 2018 David Price saga, and, as an added bonus, we'll get to say this World Series is sponsored by "YuTube."

Alas…

18. The Yankees will win the World Series
Those of us who grew up in baseball's smaller markets (or Boston) and have a natural aversion to the Yankees' stockpiling Series titles have had a pretty good run, haven't we? The Yankees have won just won championship this millennium (yes, calendrical experts will tell you the millennium began in 2001, not '00, so don't tweet me about this). By Yankee standards, that's an abyss.

But look, our luck is going to run out eventually. Since their 1919 acquisition of Babe Ruth, the Yankees have not gone a decade without a World Series appearance. The odds are against us, folks. I envision a 2019 with a more comfortable Giancarlo Stanton, a healthier Aaron Judge, a better rotation and the Yankees getting it done, with or without (likely with) Machado.

19. I will go back and read this column on Dec. 31, 2019, and cringe
This one I feel good about. Happy New Year, everybody!

https://www.mlb.com/news/predictions...on/c-302274416

[mvp 78]

Do you ever try to find anything meaningful to post?

[BillyWilliams]

Do you ever try to find anything meaningful to post?

I figured it was good fodder for debate, if you don't like it then read something else.......

[mvp 78]

I figured it was good fodder for debate, if you don't like it then read something else.......

I guess the debate would be "does BW only find weird blogs to repost that hate on the Red Sox"?

[BillyWilliams]

I guess the debate would be "does BW only find weird blogs to repost that hate on the Red Sox"?

Weird blogs? It was on the front page of MLB.com.

Seriously, go find something else to complain about ........

[mvp 78]

Seriously, go find something else to complain about ........

That's not how this works here.

[Youk Of The Nation]

There are 16 non-Red Sox/Yankees predictions on that list, maybe we could discuss some of them instead? If there isn't some actual baseball being discussed soon this thread will just be deleted.

I understand that no one likes BW. I don't like him either, because he's a Yankees fan and therefore a terrible person in every conceivable way. But he's not doing anything wrong, and despite the obvious pro-Yankee-anti-Red-Sox slant of many of the articles he posts, they are still fodder for potential baseball conversation, which is what this site is about in the end. The best way to deal with it is to lay out a genuine argument in favor of the other side rather than just yell at him for being annoying. He can't help being annoying. He's a Yankees fan, it's a serious mental illness. Have some compassion for Christ's sake.

I'll pick one: The Padres. I highly doubt they will be the "how are they this good" team. They have a few great young players but I think they're still a season or two away from even pretending to contend. They're not going to sniff .500 in 2019 unless they make an unprecedented and unanticipated splash in FA and I think we all know that's not gonna happen.

[BillyWilliams]

There are 16 non-Red Sox/Yankees predictions on that list, maybe we could discuss some of them instead? If there isn't some actual baseball being discussed soon this thread will just be deleted.

I understand that no one likes BW. I don't like him either, because he's a Yankees fan and therefore a terrible person in every conceivable way. But he's not doing anything wrong, and despite the obvious pro-Yankee-anti-Red-Sox slant of many of the articles he posts, they are still fodder for potential baseball conversation, which is what this site is about in the end. The best way to deal with it is to lay out a genuine argument in favor of the other side rather than just yell at him for being annoying. He can't help being annoying. He's a Yankees fan, it's a serious mental illness. Have some compassion for Christ's sake.

I'll pick one: The Padres. I highly doubt they will be the "how are they this good" team. They have a few great young players but I think they're still a season or two away from even pretending to contend. They're not going to sniff .500 in 2019 unless they make an unprecedented and unanticipated splash in FA and I think we all know that's not gonna happen.

That was my point to begin with, that it was an article that could create some baseball dialogue/debate during a pretty slow off season.

Seems like lvp 78 just can't handle it so he starts with personal attacks, sorry that I responded in kind.

The padres are an interesting team with a lot of young talent. Should they add a pitcher or 2 they might be within shouting distance of .500.

But it will take alot more for them to contend in that division.

[BillyWilliams]

I also hope #9 comes true, would be pretty cool for Ichiro, he deserves it.

[iortiz]

Well, last year people said that the Yankees were going to win the division as well and see how it ended up.

We are practically the same team. Yeah, We lost Kimbrel and Kelly but I won't miss them at all.

IMO Kimbrel is going to enter into a inevitable decline process and Kelly sucked most part of the season. Also, they cost a lot of money.

Said that, if the Sox stay relatively healthy, and add a BP arm and/or someone become a solid closer & set-up arm, my money will be with the Sox again.

If healthy, the Sox still have the best offense and rotation of the game. Not even close.

The only concern is the pen which could go by committee if they don't add another arm.

[Carpin]

Well, last year people said that the Yankees were going to win the division as well and see how it ended up.

We are practically the same team. Yeah, We lost Kimbrel and Kelly but I won't miss them at all.

IMO Kimbrel is going to enter into a inevitable decline process and Kelly sucked most part of the season. Also, they cost a lot of money.

Said that, if the Sox stay relatively healthy, and add a BP arm and/or someone become a solid closer & set-up arm, my money will be with the Sox again.

If healthy, the Sox still have the best offense and rotation of the game. Not even close.

The only concern is the pen which could go by committee if they don't add another arm.

I partially agree with you, specially regarding Kelly, with Kimbrel somehow he still has his velocity, I don't think his decline will be huge, at least not this year, but it will come.

Let's remember that he only undefeated is father time.

[BillyWilliams]

Well, last year people said that the Yankees were going to win the division as well and see how it ended up.

We are practically the same team. Yeah, We lost Kimbrel and Kelly but I won't miss them at all.

IMO Kimbrel is going to enter into a inevitable decline process and Kelly sucked most part of the season. Also, they cost a lot of money.

Said that, if the Sox stay relatively healthy, and add a BP arm and/or someone become a solid closer & set-up arm, my money will be with the Sox again.

If healthy, the Sox still have the best offense and rotation of the game. Not even close.

The only concern is the pen which could go by committee if they don't add another arm.

There were many who picked the sox to win the division as well.

As far as the "not even close", take off the rose colored glasses. The Yanks scored about 25 runs less last year and the difference between the 2 teams in OBP was .010, SLG was .003 and OPS was .009. As for the rotation, the sox starters ranked 9th in ERA, 7th in earned runs, 9th in BAA and 6th in WHIP. While very good, hardly what I would call "best in the game, not even close".

[iortiz]

There were many who picked the sox to win the division as well.

As far as the "not even close", take off the rose colored glasses. The Yanks scored about 25 runs less last year and the difference between the 2 teams in OBP was .010, SLG was .003 and OPS was .009. As for the rotation, the sox starters ranked 9th in ERA, 7th in earned runs, 9th in BAA and 6th in WHIP. While very good, hardly what I would call "best in the game, not even close".

They destroyed NY, HOU and LAD in the highest leverage situation you can fece and when it counts —in POs. Arguably this was the toughest path to win the WS of all time, when you look it backwards.Geez they literally destroyed Verlander, Severino and Kershaw, the last one twice. They destroyed NY´s and HOU's pens which everyone said at the time they were untouchables. Regarding pitching, Price performed like an ace in POs and was one of the best pitchers of the game in the second half of the season. Eovaldi perfomed like a Stud as well, his injury issues seem very gone —he threw several devastating 100+ mph FBs after 90+ pitches and with terrific command in many games. Porcello responded well when required, and the BP which was a mess entering into the POs, surprised everyone.

Also, remember that the Sox played practically a month with half of their engines because the PO spot was gained very early, so Cora rest a lot of people in September. Sox could have won 120 games easily and the stats you are presenting would have looked ridiculous if they had gone in winning mode.

Not to mention, we lost Sale like a month and E-Rod after a stupid injury when he was finally pitching like an ace.

Said that, again... If the Sox stay relatively healthy, Sox will be the best team in baseball again, NOT EVEN CLOSE.

[BillyWilliams]

They destroyed NY, HOU and LAD in the highest leverage situation you can fece and when it counts —in POs. Arguably this was the toughest path to win the WS of all time, when you look it backwards.Geez they literally destroyed Verlander, Severino and Kershaw, the last one twice. They destroyed NY´s and HOU's pens which everyone said at the time they were untouchables. Regarding pitching, Price performed like an ace in POs and was one of the best pitchers of the game in the second half of the season. Eovaldi perfomed like a Stud as well, his injury issues seem very gone —he threw several devastating 100+ mph FBs after 90+ pitches and with terrific command in many games. Porcello responded well when required, and the BP which was a mess entering into the POs, surprised everyone.

Also, remember that the Sox played practically a month with half of their engines because the PO spot was gained very early, so Cora rest a lot of people in September. Sox could have won 120 games easily and the stats you are presenting would have looked ridiculous if they had gone in winning mode.

Not to mention, we lost Sale like a month and E-Rod after a stupid injury when he was finally pitching like an ace.

Said that, again... If the Sox stay relatively healthy, Sox will be the best team in baseball again, NOT EVEN CLOSE.

Nonsense, they didn't "rest a lot of people". Their top players all pretty much saw 135 games plus.

Not taking anything away from their postseason performance, it was excellent, they were certainly the hottest team.

As far as injuries to sale and erod, every team has injuries and we should expect that all teams will have injuries again this coming season.

So price pitched ace level for the 2nd half? Severino pitched ace level for the 1st half until he started tipping his pitches. Not sure what that even means.

I have to laugh at eovaldi's injury issues "seem very gone". He's always had 100 mph stuff, question is whether he has turned the corner or not. Jury is still out on that.

Bottom line is I backed my statement up with stats, you backed yours up with excuses.

[iortiz]

Nonsense, they didn't "rest a lot of people". Their top players all pretty much saw 135 games plus.

Not taking anything away from their postseason performance, it was excellent, they were certainly the hottest team.

As far as injuries to sale and erod, every team has injuries and we should expect that all teams will have injuries again this coming season.

So price pitched ace level for the 2nd half? Severino pitched ace level for the 1st half until he started tipping his pitches. Not sure what that even means.

I have to laugh at eovaldi's injury issues "seem very gone". He's always had 100 mph stuff, question is whether he has turned the corner or not. Jury is still out on that.

Bottom line is I backed my statement up with stats, you backed yours up with excuses.

LOL!

I'm not backing it up with excuses. Just the opposite. Facts are all over my argument. I'm just pointing out that the Sox still have the edge —by far— to win it all again if they stay relatively healthy. As I said, we could have won 120 games easily. Geez A lot of people here included me complained at the time for dropping too many games that were very winnable in September—Again, Cora proved he was doing the right thing to win the WS. He proved us all we were wrong.

If you can't accept that Cora managed in September without the winning mode button, there's nothing more to debate.

Also, entering the POs, the apparently hottest teams were HOU and NY, and not BOS, but once again, BOS wasn't playing with all of its engines because they clinched the PO spot and the division very early, but when Cora pushed the winning mode button, you can see the results. We were way superior.

Said that, we can disagree, no big deal. Time will tell though.