The advantage of taking Herrera would be to fill an OF/DH slot, so we can trade JBJ and have a replacement- not just the tax savings.
Belt fill the 1B opening, but the savings are not much.
The Pollock/Maeda for Eovaldi/JBJ deals comes out almost dead even on the trade simulator (no money exchanging hands).
Pollock is owed $51M/3. Eovaldi is owed $51M/3.
JBJ will likely get $11.5M/1. Maeda is owed $12.5M/4.
The total money is about even, but the tax cost savings is about $13M in 2020.
I'd do this deal in a heartbeat, but it alone does not get us under the line. That's why trading Price & JBJ makes more sense.
Price & JBJ for Pollock & Joe Kelly was accepted, but I doubt the Dodgers agree to it.
We'd save $27M on the tax line, so we could afford to pay some of Price's deal, but how much would LA demand?
The actual money would be:
$96M/3 Price
$11M/1 JBJ
$51M/2 Pollock
$23M/2 Kelly
$107M to $74M in 2020 but $$96M to $74M in 2021. It's 2022 that would burn LA.
Last edited by moonslav59; 01-02-2020 at 05:19 PM.
When you say it's gonna happen now
When exactly do you mean?
When you say it's gonna happen now
When exactly do you mean?
Good one.
Championships since purchase by John Henry group: Red Sox 4 Yankees 1
The Red Sox are 8-1 in their last 9 postseason games against the Yankees.
The White Sox DFAd long time Notin favorite Tayron Guerrero. Make your move, Bloom...
Then might as well trade Xander and Devers because if all these guys are unloaded the Sox will be awful for 3-4 years .
I don’t have the answers but for the Sox to reset and be competitive in the near future they need whatever fragile pitchers they keep to suddenly become injury free and for someone like Dalbec or Casas to develop into a star in addition to some Mil
Pitchers to hit it big
The clock is now post holiday ticking with only 41 days to P& C report date, followed by position players a week later. The disposition of JBJr still in the wind, and no significant additions on the public horizon. There is a thought that despite the nosedive in 2019 thata team similar to the 2018 crew could win 90+ games if the 3 starters besides Erod can go a near full season. But that doesn't address nor solve the lux tax consideration. Likely that some potential acquirers of JBJr want the certainty of the arb process completed first.
Can someone remind me who the 5th starter is again now?
Odds are that one of the oft-injured 3 (Sale, Price, Eovaldi) will make most of their starts, one will make about half their starts, and one will miss most of the season due to injury. Having all 3 healthy for 2020 seems unlikely. But even if they are, will they all be effective?
Trading Betts and then resigning him makes a lot of sense for 2021 and beyond, but it all but ends any hopes for 2020 while hurting ticket sales and viewership, this year. If we deal Betts, why hang onto JD? He's opting out, regardless. (Again, we could bring him back, too.)
Dump Price and/or Eovaldi to open up some spending room for 2021 and 2022.
I'm not saying I want to trade Betts, but if we do, then just go for it.
When you say it's gonna happen now
When exactly do you mean?